Why is my ZZ plant turning yellow? Read the leaf pattern first

Why is my ZZ plant turning yellow: a Zamioculcas zamiifolia yellowing from its lower leaflets up in a terracotta pot.

A yellowing ZZ leaflet used to send me reaching for the watering can, which only made things worse. On a ZZ, the yellow almost always traces back to soggy soil rotting the rhizome, not thirst. I walk you through the three-look pattern check that points to the one real cause before you water again.